Contact Us 1-800-849-0772 M-F 8-3 PST



Show your Mom how much you appreciate her. She will absolutely love one of our a hand crafted Mother's Day Gift Baskets
HOME Wholesale Info 100% Guarantee


Top Trending Candy Searches: Bulk Candy, Rock Candy, Harry Potter, Mothers Day, Pez, Taffy, Lollipops, Licorice, Sugar-Free Candy, Gum
Old Fashioned Penny Candy

Old Fashioned Retro Penny Candy



Welcome to Candy Crate's Old Fashioned Penny Candy Warehouse!

Shop here for all of your favorite old fashioned candy and hard to find bulk penny candy. Although today it is usually sold for more than a penny, the name Penny Candy still refers to candy sold by the piece or as bulk penny candy. Our Retro Penny Candy selection is one of the best on the web and ships direct from our giant candy warehouse to your house. The first wrapped penny candy in America was the Tootsie Roll and has been included in many military rations since WWII.




Old Fashioned Candy Sticks
$14.94
More Info
Abba Zaba Miniatures 5LB
$44.80
All American Mint USA Salt Water Taffy 3LB
$12.99
Bulk Retro Candy Assortment
$44.95
Penny Chewy Candy Glass Jar
$29.99
Penny Hard Candy Glass Jar
$29.99
Anise Squares 5LB
$20.99
Atomic Fireballs Ferrara Pan 5LB
$19.98
Assorted Hard Sour Balls Wrapped 5LB
$19.88
Banana Taffy 3LB
$12.99
Baseball Chocolate Balls 5LB
$28.99
Bazooka Bubble Gum 5LB (DISCONTINUED)
$19.88
More Info
Bit O Honey Bulk Candy 5LB
$19.88
Black Taffy 5LB
$24.48
Brach's Jelly Bean Nougats 8.34LB
$56.85
Brach's Milk Maid Royals 6.5LB
$40.99
Brach's Strawberries 5.5LB
$38.52
Honey-Combed Filled Peanuts 5LB
$21.99
Bulls-Eyes Caramel Creams 5LB
$21.88
Butterfingers - Mini Bars 5lb (DISCONTINUED)
$24.95
More Info
Butter Toffee Hard Candy 5LB
$21.88
Butterscotch Discs 5LB (coming soon)
$19.88
More Info
Candy Necklaces Bulk 5LB
$38.88
Candy Canes Mini 500ct
$32.80
Candy Cane Salt Water Taffy 3LB (SOLD OUT)
$10.39
More Info
Chick O Stick Nuggets 5LB
$22.88
Chocolate Gold Coins 1lb
$11.90
Chocolate Conversation Hearts 5LB (Coming Soon)
$19.99
More Info
Chocolate Double Crisp Hearts 5LB
$29.99
More Info
Chocolate Lips 5LB (Coming Soon)
$19.99
More Info
Christmas Holiday Salt Water Taffy 3LB (SOLD OUT)
$10.39
More Info
Chupa Chups Assorted Lollipops 5LB
$26.80
Coffee Rio Assorted Gourmet Candies 5LB
$32.99
Goetze Cow Tales Miniature Vanilla Flavored Chewy Caramel 5LB
$29.49
Cry Baby Bubble Gum 5LB
$25.94
Dubble Bubble Gum 5LB
$21.99
Double Lollies Lollipops- Wrapped 5LB
$33.89
Dum Dum Pops 300ct.
$16.99
Egg Nog Salt Water Taffy 3LB (sold out)
$10.39
More Info
Fruit Gummy Slices 5LB (DISCONTINUED)
$18.48
More Info
Hot Buttered Rum Salt Water Taffy 3LB
$10.39
Huckleberry Purple Taffy 3LB
$12.99
Ice Blue Mint Coolers 6.5LB
$39.88
Jawbuster Jawbreakers 5LB
$19.88
Jolly Rancher Pieces Assorted 5LB
$28.40
King Leo Soft Peppermint Candy 5LB (coming soon)
$19.88
More Info
Lemonheads Ferrara Pan 5LB
$19.88
Licorice Balls Hard Candy 5LB
$21.88
Liquorice Toffee 5lb (DISCONTINUED)
$35.79
More Info
Lollipops Bulk Assorted Flavors 5LB
$19.80
Mary Janes Candy 5LB
$26.99
Milkfuls Candy 5lb (DISCONTINUED)
$24.95
More Info
Neapolitan Taffy 3LB
$12.99
Necco Banana Split Candy Chews 5LB
$19.99
Necco Wafers Mini Roll 5LB
$28.75
Necco Mint Julep Candy Chews 5LB
$19.99
Neopolitan Coconut Sundaes 5LB (Discontinued)
$29.48
More Info
Now & Later Classic Candy 5LB
$22.88
Peanut Butter Bars 5LB
$24.88
Peppermint Starlights 5LB
$15.90
Puntini Italian Jujubes 1lb
$17.71
Puntini Menta Fresca Jujubes 1lb
$17.71
Puntini Frutti Tropicali Italian Jujubes 1lb
$17.71
Puntini Chipurnoi Chips Eucalyptus Menthol Jujubes 1lb
$17.71
Puniti Chipurnoi Chips Licorice Jujubes 1lb
$17.71
SUGAR FREE ROOT BEER BARRELS 5LB (DISCONTINUED)
$34.99
More Info
Red Hot Cinnamon Discs 5LB
$19.88
Assorted Salt Water Taffy 3LB
$12.99
White and Black Licorice Salt Water Taffy 3LB
$12.99
Black Licorice Swirls Salt Water Taffy 5lb (Sold Out)
$19.88
More Info
Blue Raspberry Salt Water Taffy 5lb (Sold Out)
$19.88
More Info
Caramel Flavored Salt Water Taffy 3LB
$12.99
Cinnamon Salt Water Taffy 3LB
$12.99
Grape Salt Water Taffy 3LB (discontinued)
$12.99
More Info
Green Watermelon Salt Water Taffy 5lb (Sold Out)
$19.88
More Info
Light Blue Cotton Candy Salt Water Taffy 3LB
$12.99
Orange & Cream Salt Water Taffy 3LB
$12.99
Pina Colada Swirl Salt Water Taffy 5lb (sold out)
$19.88
More Info
Pink Bubble Gum Salt Water Taffy 3LB
$12.99
Pink Strawberry Salt Water Taffy 3LB
$12.99
Pumpkin Halloween Salt Water Taffy 3LB
$12.99
Red Licorice Swirl Salt Water Taffy 3LB
$12.99
Red & White Peppermint Salt Water Taffy 3LB
$12.99
Thank You Mint Salt Water Taffy 3LB (DISCONTINUED)
$12.99
More Info
Unicorn Pops 5LB
$31.29
Vanilla Salt Water Taffy 3LB
$12.99
Yellow Buttered Popcorn Salt Water Taffy 3LB
$12.99
Flag Salt Water Taffy 3LB
$12.99
Slo Poke Classic Caramel Bite Size Pieces 5LB
$38.48
Slo Poke Suckers 5lb (discontinued)
$29.99
More Info
Smarties Classic Candy Rolls 5LB (coming soon)
$21.29
More Info
Smarties Parties Assorted Candy 2.5LB
$13.29
Soccer Chocolate Balls 5LB (Discontinued)
$27.99
More Info
Starburst Original Fruit Chews 5lb (DISCONTINUED)
$18.80
More Info
Starburst and Skittles Variety Mix Candies 3.5lb Bag (DISCONTINUED)
$14.95
More Info
Stars and Stripes Mints 5lb (DISCONTINUED)
$24.48
More Info
Squirrel Nut Zippers 5LB
$21.99
Sunkist Fruit Gems All Natural 5lb
$38.60
SUGAR FREE Hard Tangy Fruits Candy 1lb (DISCONTINUED)
$7.99
More Info
Tootsie Midgee Rolls 5LB
$19.88
Tootsie Fruit Rolls 5LB
$19.88
USA Flag Tootsie Rolls 5LB
$19.88
Walnettos 5LB
$48.40
Watermelon Taffy 3LB
$12.99
Werther's Original Hard Candies 2lb (DISCONTINUED)
$13.99
More Info
Werther's Originals 5lb (DISCONTINUED)
$24.95
More Info
Werther's Original Caramel Coffee 5lbs (DISCONTINUED)
$24.95
More Info
Werther's Original Caramelts Candy 5lbs (DISCONTINUED)
$24.95
More Info
Chewy Sour Balls - Assorted Fruit Flavors 5LB
$19.95
Assorted 8 Flavor Dubble Bubble 1-Inch Gumballs 5LB
$22.99
Aquarium Candy Fish 5LB
$18.99
Baby Pacifiers Candy 5LB
$19.99
Baseball Dubble Bubble 1-Inch Gumballs 5LB (sold out)
$24.99
More Info
Gumballs Baseball 1-Inch Gumballs 5LB (sold out)
$22.80
More Info
Berry Blast Speckled Dubble Bubble 1-Inch Gumballs 5LB
$22.99
Black Cherry Dubble Bubble 1-Inch Gumballs 5LB
$22.99
Black Licorice Wheels 5LB
$24.99
Chewy Sour Balls - Wild Blueberry 5LB
$19.95
BONZ Dog Bone Candy 5LB
$19.40
Boston Baked Beans 5LB
$19.85
Brach's Assorted Jelly Beans 5LB (Discontinued)
$18.99
More Info
Richardson After Dinner Butter Mints 5LB
$24.99
Candy Blox 5LB
$24.95
Candy Corn 5LB
$19.99
Candy Jelly Rocks 5LB
$26.90
Centipede Gummies 5LB
$24.99
Chocolate Candy Rocks 5LB
$34.99
Richardson Gourmet Chocolate Mints 5LB
$35.99
Cherry Candy Hearts 5LB
$21.99
Chewy Sour Balls - Cherry 5LB
$19.95
Cherry Sour Gummies 5LB
$24.99
Chewy Spree Candy 5LB
$19.89
Chocolate Stars 5LB
$25.99
CHICLE CHEWS MINI 5lb (DISCONTINUED)
$21.99
More Info
Christmas Jelly Bells 5LB (Sold Out)
$18.48
More Info
Cinnamon Bears 5LB
$19.99
Cinnamon Bear Sugar Free Cubbies 1LB
$9.99
Cinnamon Red Hots Hearts 5lb (DISCONTINUED)
$22.48
More Info
Chocolate Stars - Brach's Solid Milk Chocolate Stars 12oz
$6.72
CLASSIC Conversation Hearts 5LB
$19.99
Cotton Candy Dubble Bubble 1-Inch Gumballs 5LB
$21.99
Double Lollies - Unwrapped 5LB
$24.99
Dubble Bubble Chiclets Bubble Gum 5LB
$21.99
Dutch Sea Salt Licorice 1.65LB
$12.99
Easter Bunny Kisses Salt Water Taffy 3lb (Coming Soon)
$10.39
More Info
Easter Jelly Rabbits 5LB (Sold out)
$19.99
More Info
Finnska Soft Licorice 8.8LB
$59.99
Flower Power Candies 5LB
$18.99
Fruit Salad Gummies 5lb (DISCONTINUED)
$24.99
More Info
Purple Grape Dubble Bubble 1-Inch Gumballs 5LB
$22.99
Green Apple Dubble Bubble 1-Inch Gumballs 5LB
$22.99
Green Watermelon Dubble Bubble 1-Inch Gumballs 5LB
$21.99
Gummi Gold Bears 5LB
$24.99
Gustaf's Platinum Select Royal Rounds 2.2lbs. (DISCONTINUED)
$19.99
More Info
Gustaf's Platinum Select Sweet Licorice
$19.99
Gustaf's Platinum Select Touch Of Italy Licorice
$19.99
Gustaf's Wine Gums 2.2LB
$19.80
Gummi Raspberries & Blackberries 5LB
$24.99
Gummy Red Raspberries 5LB
$21.80
Gumballs Assorted 1/2-Inch 5LB
$21.99
Gumballs Assorted 1-Inch Large 5LB
$22.80
Happy Cola Gummy Candy Bottles 5LB
$24.99
Hot Chew Dubble Bubble 1-Inch Gumballs 5LB
$21.99
HOT TAMALES 4.5LB
$19.88
Ice Cream Cone Candy 5LB
$19.99
Jelly Beans Black 5LB
$21.74
Jelly Beans Assorted 5LB
$19.80
Jelly Belly Individual Flavors 10LB
$88.16
More Info
Jelly Belly Gumballs Large 5lb (DISCONTINUED)
$28.29
More Info
Jelly Belly 49 Assorted Flavors 10LB
$88.16
Jelly Belly Tropical Mix 10LB
$88.16
Jelly Belly Fruit Bowl Flavors 10LB
$88.16
Jelly Beans Speckled 5LB (sold out)
$21.74
More Info
Jelly Belly Champagne Bubbles 5LB
$41.89
Richardson After Dinner Jelly Filled Mints 5LB (DISCONTINUED)
$24.99
More Info
Licorice Scottie Dogs - BLACK 5LB
$29.78
Licorice Scottie Dogs - RED 5LB
$29.78
Liquorice Caramels from Holland 4.4LB
$37.99
Chewy Sour Balls - Light Green Margarita 5LB (DISCONTINUED)
$19.95
More Info
Mellowcreme Pumpkins 5lb (DISCONTINUED)
$19.48
More Info
Mellowcreme Autumn Mix 5lb (Discontinued)
$19.48
More Info
Fiesta Mexican Hats Candy 5LBS
$24.78
Mike & Ike Original Fruits 4.5LB
$19.88
Mini Gummy Frogs 5lb (DISCONTINUED)
$24.99
More Info
Neon Candy Stars 5LB
$17.99
Richardson After Dinner Pastel Mints 5LB
$24.99
Peach Gummies 5LB
$24.99
Pink Original Dubble Bubble 1-Inch Gumballs 5LB
$21.99
Pink Chiclets Dubble Bubble Bubble Gum 5LB
$22.99
Pink Lemonade Dubble Bubble 1-Inch Gumballs 5LB
$21.99
Chewy Sour Balls - Pink Watermelon 5LB
$19.95
Red JuJu Coins 5LB
$19.99
Runts Fruit Candy 5LB
$19.95
Gustaf's Salt Licorice Coins 2.2LB
$19.99
Skulls Candy 5LB
$21.99
Gustaf's Soft Licorice Drops From Holland 2.2LB
$19.99
Sour Patch Kids 5LB
$28.80
Spice Drops 5LB (Sold Out)
$19.99
More Info
Smiley Dubble Bubble Gumballs 1 inch 5lb (DISCONTINUED)
$21.99
More Info
Strawberry Licorice Wheels 5LB
$24.99
Sugar Free Gum Balls 5LB
$39.80
Gustaf's Sugar Free Licorice Bears 2.2LB
$19.99
Sugar Free Gustaf's Licorice Coins 2.2LB
$19.99
Sugar Free Gustaf's Licorice Drops 2.2LB
$19.99
Sugar Free Licorice Scottie Dogs - RED 1LB
$10.99
Sugar Free Licorice Scottie Dogs - BLACK 1LB
$10.99
Sunkist Orange Slices 5lb. (DISCONTINUED)
$34.99
More Info
Swedish Fish Assorted 5LB
$21.99
Swedish Fish Red 5LB
$21.99
Sweet Talkin' Valentine Salt Water Taffy 1LB (Coming Soon)
$7.99
More Info
Teddy Bears Candy 5LB
$23.99
Twin Cherries Gummy 5LB
$24.99
Nik-L-Nip Wax Bottles 5LB
$24.88
Nik-L-Nip Wax Candy Sticks 5LB
$24.88
Winner Dubble Bubble Gumballs 1 inch 5lb (DISCONTINUED)
$21.99
More Info
Big Hunk Miniatures 5LB
$44.80
Puntini Sambuca Chewy Miniature Jujubes 1lb
$17.71
Puntini Cinnamon Chewy Miniature Jujubes 1lb.
$17.71
Puntini Petite Deceit Sugar Free Assorted Fruit Flavors 1lb
$23.03

  • SAVE 5% on your order Today! Use Promo code ~ sweetsavings
  • ORDERS PLACED BY 5PM EST (2PM PST) SHIP SAME BUSINESS DAY M-F
  • SAVE 5% on your order Today! Use Promo code ~ sweetsavings
  • Your confidential information is protected by 256bit SSL Secure Servers!

Your order is shipped the same business day when placed by 2 pm PST. and comes with a 100% guarantee!

Like us on Facebook, follow us on Twitter and check out our Candy Blog for all the latest candy news, events and Candy Crate specials.
Email
Enter your email address to receive an INSTANT coupon via email...
We NEVER share email addresses or personal information!
The website was easy to navigate - checking out was simple and Candy Crate kept in touch with delivery times, etc. My gift recipient received my order in time and was very satisfied. I recommend Candycrate.com to others. Excellent product, good value, on-time delivery. Thank you! Loretta V.
Candy Crate has the most selection and best prices. The Customer Service provided is fantastic and no one else comes close to the quality of your products. I will be back and I have recommeded Candy Crate to all my friends. Keep up the good work!!!
Darlene R.
I was worried about the condition the candies would come in, since they are very fragile. Candy Crate did an excellent job making sure they were protected from rough travel. Thanks!
J. McBurrows
It arrived as a gift to a friend earlier than I thought which was GREAT, especially since it went to Hawaii. My brother-in-law loved it - not only the novelty of it, but the candy was really good too.
Cathy S.
Great product! My dad loved his gift of retro candy! Will definitely buy from them again!
Excellent... I pleased with how quickly my order was shipped & how cheap your products were compaired to other websites. Thank You for everything.
Dear Candy Crate, I recently ordered from you and just wanted you to know how delighted I was not only with the candy and it's freshness but also the SHIPPING! I am in Texas and it is hot here. I did order the 2 day faster shipping with the ice pack - and the candy arrived in tip-top shape - fresh and crisp in each box upon arrival. The candy was a BIG hit - something the recipient had not seen since childhood - she was delighted !!!!
G. Gardner
view all >
All content included on this site is the property of Candy Crate, Inc. or its content suppliers and protected by United States and international copyright laws. The compilation of all content, articles, and images on this site is the exclusive property of candycrate.com© and protected by U.S. and international copyright laws.
Candy Crate is an Upfront Merchant on TheFind. Click for info. A+ Member
Old Fashioned Penny Candy